Saturday, 3 October 2026

Sir John Melville Was Put in an Awkward Position by Queen Elizabeth: She Asked the Scottish Ambassador Whether She Was Fairer Than His Queen

Share
Sir John Melville Was Put in an Awkward Position by Queen Elizabeth: She Asked the Scottish Ambassador Whether She Was Fairer Than His Queen

Sir John Melville was put in an awkward position by Queen Elizabeth: she asked the Scottish ambassador whether she was fairer than his queen. Melville replied that "Elizabeth is the fairest queen in England, and Mary the fairest in Scotland". Which of us dances better, then? Elizabeth pressed on. In any case, Queen Mary does not dance so high or so freely. Small wonder, given Mary Stuart's poor health, her constant muscular weakness and her nervous attacks; it is astonishing that she had the strength for dancing at all.

Some sources ascribe the same exchange to the Venetian ambassador, perhaps by mistake, or perhaps the queen simply repeated herself in her whims.

In the painting, Elizabeth dances the old dance La Volta with her favourite, Robert Dudley, at Penshurst Castle.

Report a translation error